Work-as-imagined vs work-as-done: examples
In the current edition of Safeguard magazine Dr Hillary Bennett says that in her experience, the concept of work-as-imagined vs work-as-done really gets people's attention.
What is the biggest gap between work-as-imagined and work-as-done that you have encountered? What impact could that have on health & safety outcomes?
You can respond in public here on the Forum, or privately
via a Survey Monkey form.
An edited selection of responses will be published in the July/Aug edition, but with no names attached. One randomly selected person will receive a prize!
I like this idea. It reminds me of what used to happen in the early days of the ACC - WSMP programme. I'm referring to the difference between the controls that were supposedly (imagined to be) in place with regards to the hazards listed in the hazard (risk) register; compared to the actual controls (or complete absence of) that the auditor found. That was after ACC insisted that auditors verify that what was actually being done, matched what the documentation said was being done.
I remember encountering a fire engineering contractor who had provided a 'beautiful' safe system of work for replacing a sensor head. This written system of work included the use of an elevated work platform; the contractor, however, had come armed with a ladder.
It was a 5 minute job and the ladder was the perfect tool for the job. The contractor told me that "the paperwork couldn't mention a ladder, because ladders are banned on most sites".
I just got him to quickly amend the paperwork in pen, so it resembled what he was actually going to do and away he went. Problem was, the paperwork took longer than the job did!
This happens all too often. People/contractors write a plan then do the complete opposite. Usually the plan includes 'what the principle wants to hear, not what is actually going to occur'.
Having done a multitude of FRAM modelling workshops produces way too many differences between WAI and WAD. However, I have had a variety of reactions after FRAM modelling a task such as "I never knew my job was so complex", or (in jest) "I need to ask the boss for a pay rise".
I had a similar one but they decide to wait until a stock truck drove in and stood on that.
Sign in or register to add a comment.
Add a Comment
Welcome to the Safeguard forum!
Health & safety reps
Start a discussion
Ask a question
Calling for focus group participants - Companies who use labour hire / temporary work agencies
Young Workers' Vulnerability to Work-Related Harm
Masks where wet, heavy physical work is performed
Notifiable work - all contractors or only the main contractor to notify?
Terms of Service
Useful Hints and Tips
Created with PlushForums
© 2021 Safeguard Forum